Peter Pan Goes Wrong
September 25 – October 18, 2026
By Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayers & Henry Shields

Brace yourselves for an awfully big adventure when the inept and accident-prone Cornley Drama Society set out to present J.M. Barrie’s much-loved classic tale of Peter Pan, their most audacious production to date. What ensues is two acts of hysterical disaster, battling technical hitches, flying mishaps and cast disputes. But will they ever make it to Neverland?

You’ll laugh; they’ll cry. Something so wrong has never been so right. Containing the same potent blend of hilarity that features in their award-winning The Play That Goes Wrong, Mischief’s take on Peter Pan is unforgettable, even if the Cornley Drama Society wish they could forget what just happened.
Rated PG

Nominee: 2016 Olivier Awards
Winner! 2023 Drama Desk Awards, Unique Theatrical Experience
Nominee: Three Drama Desk Awards

Rodgers + Hammerstein’s Cinderella
November 27 – December 13, 2026
Music by Richard Rodgers, Lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II, New Book by Douglas Carter Beane, Original Book by Oscar Hammerstein II

The timeless enchantment of a magical fairy tale is reborn with the Rodgers & Hammerstein hallmarks of originality, charm and elegance. Originally presented on television in 1957 starring Julie Andrews, Rodgers & Hammerstein’s Cinderella was the most widely viewed program in the history of the medium. This contemporary take on the classic tale features Rodgers & Hammerstein’s most beloved songs, including “In My Own Little Corner,” “Impossible/It’s Possible” and “Ten Minutes Ago,” alongside an up-to-date, hilarious and romantic libretto by Tony Award nominee Douglas Carter Beane.
Rated G

Nominee: Nine 2013 Tony Awards, including Best Book of a Musical and Best Revival of a Musical
Winner! 2014 Tony Award for Best Costume Design for a Musical
Winner! Three 2013 Drama Desk Awards, including Outstanding Orchestrations

The Importance of Being Earnest
January 29 – February 14, 2027
A Play by Oscar Wilde

First performed in 1895, this timeless comedy follows two bachelors who invent alter egos to outwit society and find love. As their deception unravels, chaos and hilarity ensue. Experience mistaken identities, secret loves, and sparkling satire in one of Oscar Wilde’s most celebrated work.
Rated PG for mild mature content.

Winner! 2011 Tony Awards
Nominee: Three 2011 Tony Awards
Winner! 2011 Drama Desk Award
Nominee: Three 2011 Drama Desk Awards

Appropriate
March 26 – April 11, 2027
By Branden Jacobs-Jenkins

It’s summer, the cicadas are singing, and the Lafayette family has returned to their late patriarch’s Arkansas home to deal with the remains of his estate. Toni, the eldest daughter, hopes they’ll spend the weekend remembering and reconnecting over their beloved father. Bo, her brother, wants to recoup some of the funds he spent caring for Dad at the end of his life. But things take a turn when their estranged brother, Franz, appears late one night, and mysterious objects are discovered among the clutter. Suddenly, long-hidden secrets and buried resentments can’t be contained, and the family is forced to face the ghosts of their past.
Rated PG-13 for mature themes, including strong language (profanity and racial slurs), depictions of trauma (grief, addiction, abuse, and mental health challenges), the legacy of racism in America, physical violence, and references to sexual situations and adult relationships.

Winner! Three 2024 Tony Awards, including Best Revival of a Play
Winner! Three 2024 Drama Desk Awards, including Outstanding Revival of a Play
Nominee: Seven 2024 Tony Awards
Nominee: Seven 2024 Drama Desk Awards
Winner! 2014 Obie Award for Best New American Play

Dear Evan Hansen
May 21 – June 11, 2027
Book by Steven Levenson
Music and Lyrics by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul

Seventeen-year-old Evan Hansen has felt invisible his entire life. But when a tragedy shocks his community and thrusts him into the center of a rapidly evolving controversy, Evan is given the opportunity of a lifetime: the chance to be somebody else. As his web of well-intentioned lies begins to unravel, though, Evan is forced to confront the fact that the price of belonging may be far steeper than he bargained for.
Rated PG-13 for mature content and language, drugs and alcohol, violence, and sexual content.

Winner! Six 2017 Tony Awards, including Best Musical and Best Original Score
Nominee: Nine 2017 Tony Awards
Winner! 2018 Grammy Awards, Best Musical Theater Album
Winner! Three 2020 Olivier Awards, including Best New Musical and Best Original Score
Nominee: Five 2020 Olivier Awards

The Minutes
October 9 – November 1, 2026
By Tracy Letts

A town’s proud history, the legend of a local hero, the coveted privilege of reserved parking: nothing is sacred during the town council meeting. This razor-sharp comedy turns from hilarious to chilling as petty policy matters give way to the truth roiling just beneath the surface of the town’s historical mythology.
Rated PG-13 for strong language and mature themes, including depictions of violence, racism, and trauma.

Finalist: 2018 Pulitzer Prize for Drama
Nominee: 2022 Tony Award for Best Play

It’s A Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play
December 4 – 20, 2026
Adapted by Joe Landry, Based on the story “The Greatest Gift” by Philip van Doren Stern

This beloved American holiday classic comes to captivating life as a live 1940s radio broadcast. With the help of an ensemble that brings a few dozen characters to the stage, the story of idealistic George Bailey unfolds as he considers ending his life one fateful Christmas Eve. When an angel, Clarence, shows him the positive impact he has had on his family and the people around him George realizes that he is loved.
Rated PG

Matt & Ben
February 12 – 28, 2027
By Mindy Kaling, Brenda Withers

Matt & Ben depicts its Hollywood golden boys – before J-Lo, before Gwyneth, before Project Greenlight, before Oscar… before anyone actually gave a damn. When the screenplay for Good Will Hunting drops mysteriously from the heavens, the boys realize they’re being tested by a Higher Power.
Rated PG-13 for strong language, mature themes, violence/slapstick, and substance use.

Winner! 2002 New York International Fringe Festival, Best Overall Production

Trouble in Mind
April 16 – May 2, 2027
By Alice Childress

Wiletta Mayer, an African American actress of a certain age, has spent her career playing stereotypes, trapped on a merry-go-round of mammies, maids, and other menials. The curtain rises on the first day of rehearsal for Chaos in Belleville, a Broadway-bound play that tackles the harsh truths of racism in America. But when those truths spill out of the play and into the rehearsal hall, will Wiletta’s insistence on her dignity cost her the work she desperately needs?
Rated PG-13: Set in the 1950s, this play tackles themes of racism and sexism and includes the use of profanity and racially offensive terms. 

Nominee: Four 2022 Tony Award, including Best Revival of a Play
Nominee: Two 2022 Drama Desk Awards, including Outstanding Revival of a Play